Reviews

5/5 Stars - Really good podcast

I love listening to these two! They're so funny together and you can tell they actually like each other, which makes a huge difference. They do a good job researching the cases and they're not afraid to call the bad guys (or gals!) what they are - dirtbags…lol What I really like is they keep things interesting but respectful to the victims and families. anything like. They actually care about telling the story right.

Startruks
June 8, 2025

The perfect podcast

I'm usually a one-host podcast person, but Christie and Melissa have somehow made work. These two hosts have incredible chemistry without any of that annoying fake banter that makes me want to skip episodes…and the bloopers are like the dessert of the episodes 😆 The quality is absolutely top-notch—fantastic audio, editing, and none of those jarring volume changes that plague other shows. You can tell they actually invest in good equipment and know what they're doing. Seriously, it’s better than many professional podcasters that have been around for much longer. What I love most is how they handle the content. No unnecessary crude language, no random political rants (or even subtle jabs that many podcasters can’t help but to include) just storytelling that doesn't sacrifice being engaging.

Nathang33
June 5, 2025

Don’t go

I will miss you guys don’t go

ciroben
June 5, 2025

Grace to the crime, and small bit of giggles

These wonderful ladies give a great mix of the care to the victim, and the story of how the ‘Dirtbag’ got there. They deliver the story with care and a bit of a giggle here and there, while keeping so much dignity to the real story. This is a great podcast, and I look forward to every new episode.

Kb4901
May 24, 2025

Happy to Give 5 stars but

Eh-specially. Especially. NOT ek-specially. I’d be unbothered if it wasn’t mispronounced multiple times each episode but it is and it irks me. I will gladly take the dialect quirk that makes them say, “dirtbaigs” but the “ekspecially” pronunciation drives me nuts. If this is addressed, it’s easily a 5-star podcast.

Clb4211
March 2, 2025

The best true crime podcast

I absolutely love this podcast, detailed coverage and back stories. Not too much banter or personal details, straight to the point. Soothing voices with a cute Canadian accent. Wish there were more episodes!

J0rgIa
Jan. 9, 2025

I love you Canadians

I love your show. I grew up in Detroit, MI going to Windsor and Toronto for family reunions and your “accents” feel so familiar. Your voices are warm and kind and the way you tell these awful stories is relatable. Thank you for kindness and accuracy in telling them. I will always listen! Edit to add: the way you keep it clean is beyond superb and appreciated!!! Ugh! Sooo much! Thank you ladies!

Amandapandaprose
Nov. 27, 2024

The dirtiest of bags!

I love your podcast! I discovered you through Brandon via Rich and Tina! Thanks for doing that major heartbreak colab. I love the insight you have in the cases, your compassion, the details especially the gory ones, and your accents! I have been binging all the episodes and I can’t get enough. 🩸❤️🩸 Ps. I love your intro and outro. Who wrote it? I want it as my ringtone!

moxiebleu
Nov. 14, 2024

The dirtiest of bags!

I love your podcast! I discovered you through Brandon via Rich and Tina! Thanks for doing that major heartbreak colab. I love the insight you have in the cases, your compassion, the details especially the gory ones, and your accents! I have been binging all the episodes and I can’t get enough. 🩸❤️🩸

moxiebleu
Oct. 31, 2024

Best yet

I always listen to it on my way to places I also don’t know if they are telling the truth or if it’s a lie but it’s a awesome podcast and I love it so much

Hbvjjvnfhjhrj
March 29, 2024

Love this podcast

I love this true crime podcast. It’s refreshing to have the hosts of a podcast share their true feelings about the case, feels very genuine. Also love the outtakes at the end of the show because it helps you leave off on a lighter note. Great podcast!!

Mayyyraa0027
Aug. 31, 2023

Favorite new podcast!

I found this podcast about a week ago and I have been binging! I love the way you guys tell each person’s story, and I love that this is a clean podcast! Keep up the great work, ladies ☺️

K_orme
Aug. 31, 2023

Love this podcast!!

I recently found this podcast and it’s quickly become a favorite of mine! Christie and Melissa have great chemistry and know how to tell a true crime story that will keep you interested throughout. I can’t wait to hear what dirtbag they feature next!!!

Laddyla
July 12, 2023

Oh ya, he's a dirt bag...

I love this podcast as much for the cute hosts as anything else. Their accents remind me of Mont Rose, Minnesota and they can be talking about the most awful dirtbag and still manage to sound like your favorite aunt who's bring you a plate of warm peanut butter cookies. After listening to many of the more shrill podcasts where the F-bomb is dropped every other word while the hosts scream with laughter at their own jokes, this podcast is a welcome reliefc too my ear. Thank you!

Otolith 2000
April 15, 2023

Obsessed

I have been listening to true crime podcasts for quite some time now but I’ve never found a show that pulled me right in like Buried Motives! I’ve shared with all of my friends and can’t wait for the new episodes every week! I appreciate all the work they’ve put in and hope this continues on for many years to come!

Jclouse1
March 15, 2023

Ah-ddicted to this podcast!

I started listening to this podcast a few months ago and I’m completely addicted! Christy and Melissa are a joy to listen to and offer a lighthearted take on true crime (as much as possible). The bloopers at the end of each episode are adorable!

MissMeg0720
Feb. 28, 2023

Loving the ‘Clean’ True Crime Stories

I love that there is not an f-bomb every fifth word. The chemistry between Melissa and Christy is great. I just discovered you guys, but I’ve binged almost half of the episodes in just a few days.

Melissa Atkinson
Feb. 2, 2023

I now look forward to Thursdays!

It’s so refreshing to listen to a podcast where the police are not broad brushed as the bad guys. On another note, I typically don’t like podcasts where there are 2 hosts but this just works!

trucrimemamma
Dec. 1, 2022

my favorite podcast!!! 10/10

it’s crazy how underrated this podcast is, i genuinely can't point out a single flaw in it! the sound quality: amazing. the personalities: fantastic. the story telling: awesome. i’ve listened to every episode and am thrilled each time a new one comes out. i love the amount of detail they cover too! it’s so interesting to hear how these killers turned out this way, not just what happened. buried motives has set my standards for true crime podcasts way too high! curse you guys for making such great content! keep it up :) also would love if u guys made a patreon for exclusive stuff, even if it’s just behind the scenes or extra info.

dalesnotokay
Nov. 19, 2022

Love it!

Super fascinating murder cases with a side of laughter! Not that there’s anything funny about murder, but you ladies literally make me laugh out loud sometimes! I love this podcast so much!

MomsTheWord1719
Sept. 27, 2022

Love this pod

You ladies are hilarious!!! I just found your pod and am binging while I’m at work. Omg, the Lysol ads had me rolling!!! Yes, yes I did look them up. You never know what new fun facts that you will learn while listening to true crime 😂😂😂😂 Keep it up ladies!!!

Ktbn64
June 23, 2022

Love

Great true crime podcast. These ladies do a wonderful job in researching each case and tell them in a very captivating way ..it’s like discussing true crime with your best friends! Give them a listen!

xLynzNicolex
March 31, 2022

Fresh and a great listen

I really enjoy the chemistry between Christie and Melissa. They have a fresh approach and episodes on events I have not heard before. So happy to have found this gem 💎.

CrystalC233
Nov. 22, 2021